Real Estate Holding Companies and Asset Protection: Why Florida’s Lack of Protection for Single-Member LLCs Should Be A Concern
One of the most common reasons our clients form limited liability companies is for asset protection. When properly formed, a real estate holding company should create a barrier between your personal assets and the company’s assets. However, for single-member LLCs in Florida, the barrier is not as strong as you might think under current limited liability company law.
What is a Single-Member LLC?
A single-member LLC is a limited liability company with one owner, or “member.” This structure is popular among real estate investors, freelancers, and small business owners due to its simplicity and tax benefits. But when it comes to LLC liability protections in Florida, single-member entities are more vulnerable than they appear.
The Problem with Florida’s LLC Laws
Florida’s limited liability company laws do not afford single-member LLCs the same protections as multi-member LLCs. This difference can lead to major financial risks for business owners who rely on this structure.
Key Legal Vulnerabilities of Florida Single-Member LLCs
- Charging Orders and Creditors:
In a multi-member LLC, creditors generally cannot seize company assets to satisfy a member’s personal debts. Instead, they obtain a court-issued “charging order,” which allows the creditor to seize a debtor’s share of distributions from the LLC.
In the case of single-member LLCs, Florida courts have ruled that creditors can bypass charging orders and directly access the assets of the LLC. This exception to traditional limited liability company protections significantly weakens the asset protection most owners expect.
- Piercing the Corporate Veil:
Courts in Florida are more likely to “pierce the corporate veil” in single-member LLCs, allowing creditors to hold the owner personally liable for business debts. This risk increases if the owner fails to maintain clear separation between personal and business finances or uses the LLC improperly.
As a result, the LLC’s assets are vulnerable to the member’s individual debt and the individual’s assets are vulnerable to the LLC’s debt—an outcome that undermines the purpose of forming a limited liability company.
How to Strengthen Your Legal Protections
If you’re considering forming a single-member LLC in Florida, here are a few proactive strategies to help safeguard your assets and strengthen your position under Florida’s limited liability company law:
- Maintain Business Formalities: Keep detailed records and minutes for business activities and maintain completely separate personal and business finances.
- Consider Adding a Member: Even a nominal membership interest given to a trusted individual can shift your LLC from a single-member to a multi-member structure, increasing legal protections.
- Evaluate Other States: You may decide to incorporate in a state that offers more robust protections to single member LLCs.
- Get The Right Insurance: Liability and umbrella insurance can provide extra protection beyond what is offered under current Florida LLC law.
Conclusion: Know the Law, Reduce Your Risk
While forming a single-member LLC is a common strategy for real estate investors and entrepreneurs, it’s important to understand the limitations of Florida’s limited liability company law. By recognizing the risks and taking protective steps — with the right legal guidance — you can better shield your personal assets and strengthen your business structure. Contact our firm today to schedule a complimentary consultation.
